GiveLoginCreate AccountCurrent StudentsSearch

Public Forum · Submission resources

Submission Guidelines & Examples

Understand what an Opinion or Challenge brief is, what it must include, and the standards it must meet before publication review.

Public to readMember account required to submitStandards revised July 20, 2026

Know the standard before you begin.

These requirements apply to Public Forum Opinions and Challenges. The resources show you how to meet the format; they do not write, edit, or judge your work. Everyone who takes part must also follow the Public Forum Rules, which cover conduct, moderation, and how to ask for a review.

01 · The submission

What a Public Forum brief is

A brief is a structured written submission that places an argument into the Public Forum record. It identifies the issue, states one main argument, presents the evidence, explains the reasoning, and connects each supporting argument to the main argument.

Opinion brief

Begins a public position. It states a neutral topic question, the member's position, one main argument, relevant context, supporting arguments, and sources.

Challenge brief

Addresses an accepted Opinion. It identifies the exact claim being challenged and explains the defect in that claim's evidence, reasoning, interpretation, or connection.

02 · Required contents

What every brief must include

  1. A clear title and the correct filing type.
  2. One main argument or main challenge.
  3. Relevant context sufficient to understand the issue.
  4. Supporting arguments tied directly to the main argument or challenged claim.
  5. Evidence and verifiable sources for factual or source-dependent claims.
  6. The author's reasoning connecting the evidence to the conclusion.
  7. Consistent citations and the required submission information.
Length: Opinion and Challenge briefs are 200-3,000 words. Citations and footnotes are excluded from the count.

03 · Publication review

Academic/professional and mechanics standards

Both standards must be satisfied before a brief proceeds to publication review. The member is responsible for submitting complete, publish-ready work.

Academic/professional

Follow the designated template; cite each non-common-knowledge claim; use verifiable and authoritative sources; represent quotations and evidence accurately; submit original work; avoid plagiarism, fabrication, and deliberate source misuse.

Mechanics

State a clear main argument; connect supporting arguments to it; connect evidence through reasoning; organize ideas logically; use helpful headings and guideposts; apply correct grammar, spelling, punctuation, and consistent citation formatting.

The Institute does not edit the submission. Members complete their own spelling, grammar, citation, evidence, and logic review before filing. Ordinary correctable failures may be returned with comments tied to the published standard.

04 · Argument requirements

Use these four logic checks

These checks show how to apply the governing argument rules. They do not predict whether an argument will prevail.

1
Complete the argument.

State the claim, provide evidence, explain the reasoning, and show how the point connects to the main argument or challenged claim.

2
Stay directly relevant.

An Opinion support must advance its main argument. A Challenge must address the exact claim, evidence, interpretation, reasoning step, or connection it disputes.

3
Replace assertion with support.

A bare claim is not enough. Identify the source actually used and explain what the evidence establishes without misstatement or overreach.

4
Test each supporting line.

Ask whether the supporting argument is necessary, whether its evidence is adequate, and whether the conclusion follows from the reasons provided.

Public Forum argument review adds three comparison measures. Review considers consistency with established facts and expert consensus unless the contrary evidence sufficiently dismantles them; the number of arguments that stand; and the absence of errors linked to claims or conclusions, including logic errors, unreasonable interpretation, and misstatement or misquotation of evidence. The preparation tools display these rules but do not score them.

05 · Preparation help

Prepare your submission

Review annotated Opinion and Challenge examples, or open a blank structured template. The tools provide headings, prompts, source organization, consistent formatting, and a mechanical checklist. They do not supply arguments, sources, edits, or conclusions.

Tools & Templates

Use a blank Opinion or Challenge workspace to format and polish your submission for publication review.

06 · After you file

Changing or withdrawing a brief

You can edit a brief while it is a draft. After you send it, you may take it back to edit or withdraw it until intake makes a decision. After a decision, the brief is not edited: a returned brief comes back as a new linked revision, and an accepted or published brief is never changed. To fix a mistake in a published record, ask the panel for a correction; it is added as a dated note and the original stays in the record.